Amplify vs Shopify (2025): SMB eCommerce ROI, Conversion & Cart Recovery
For small and mid-sized retailers, choosing between Amplify and Shopify means balancing cost, conversion, and ROI.
For small and mid-sized retailers, choosing between Amplify and Shopify means balancing cost, conversion, and ROI. Shopify dominates brand recognition but adds hidden costs and slower recovery. Amplify flips the model with free builds, integrated optimization, and stronger ROI.
Quick Verdict: Amplify vs Shopify
Shopify delivers reach and integrations but at a premium—transaction fees, reliance on apps, and slower ROI. Amplify is built for SMB retailers: free professional build, conversion-optimized checkout, and integrated recovery that lifts ROI faster.
👉 Download the E-commerce ROI Study
Conversion & Cart Recovery Side-by-Side
Factor | Amplify | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
Avg Conversion Rate | 2.8–3.1% (CRO built-in) | 1.8–2.5% (industry avg) |
Cart Abandonment Recovery | Integrated tools: +20–30% more carts recovered | Requires paid apps, limited recovery |
Transaction/App Costs | Free $4K+ build + hosting | $79+/mo + $9–$49/app |
ROI Timeline | Positive ROI in 90 days (SMB case data) | ROI delayed by higher costs & apps |
Verdict: Amplify outperforms Shopify in conversion lift and recovery—critical for SMB retailers.
Why Shopify Costs SMBs More
Transaction & App Fees
Shopify charges subscription + transaction fees, plus recovery tools often require paid apps.
Dependency on Plugins
Abandoned cart recovery, SMS, and advanced email sequences require multiple apps, each adding cost.
Time-to-Launch
SMBs spend weeks configuring apps before seeing ROI.
Why Amplify Wins on ROI
Free $4K+ Professional Build saves SMBs upfront costs.
Conversion-Optimized Checkout boosts SMB conversion from 2% to 3%+.
Integrated Recovery & Analytics recover 20–30% more carts than Shopify’s app setups.
FAQs: Amplify vs Shopify
Is Shopify good for SMBs?
Yes, but costs rise with apps and fees. Amplify provides a lower-cost, higher-ROI path.
What’s the difference in recovery rates?
Amplify’s integrated tools recover 20–30% more carts than Shopify’s baseline app setup.
Does Amplify match Shopify’s design quality?
Yes. Amplify delivers a free $4K+ professional build, optimized for SMB conversion.
How fast can SMBs see ROI with Amplify?
Case data shows ROI within 90 days, faster than Shopify setups weighed down by fees.
Final Verdict: SMBs Choosing Amplify
Shopify dominates in brand recognition, but SMB retailers often pay for it with higher fees and slower ROI. Amplify flips the model: free professional build, integrated recovery, higher conversions, and lower total cost.
